Ward Question – 21 February 2008

Back

 

Under Standing Order 14, Councilllor Caroline Nichols asked the following question:

“In response to Spelthorne Borough Council's tender, the plan for extra-care homes on the Benwell Day Centre site is at a density approaching 200 per hectare, and with no amenity space.  Bearing in mind that the Borough's first extra-care development - Beechwood Court - was built at half this proposed density, and Housing Corporation extra-care standards favour lower densities, why does the Portfolio Holder believe 200 homes per hectare is acceptable?”

 

Councillor Mrs V.J. Leighton responded as follows:

“For accuracy, the actual density of the proposed Benwell Day Centre is 170 dwellings per hectare.  When flats are being built they will inevitably be at a much higher density than for houses.  What also needs to be borne in mind, is that Extracare housing is a different concept, with the key issue being that the project is built to Department of Health Guidelines.

With respect to the amenity space, half of the flats have some form of balcony or patio and there will be a communal outdoor area which will be of high quality.  In addition to the outdoor amenity space, there will also be a resident’s lounge on the ground floor. 

The Beechwood Court development was a replacement for sheltered housing on an existing site.  It should be noted that the facilities are not the same and Beechwood does not have a day centre for the community.

In summary, the Benwell project is for the older person. Research shows that the facility is likely to be occupied by over 75’s with differing care needs, and, as the facility will be built specifically to Department of Health Guidelines, the Benwell will not follow traditional planning guidance.  Therefore, the Benwell will indeed be the Borough’s first extra care facility and will be different from sheltered housing, nursing homes and residential homes.  I have no doubt that the proposed building will provide an alternative choice and will enable older people, who would not otherwise be able to do so, to live independently, in their own home with their own front door.”

 

In accordance with Standing Order 14.2, Councillor Mrs C.E. Nichols asked the following supplementary question:

“Can I take it that in future, extra care homes (as in LDF 6) are going to be at a higher density?”

 

The Portfolio Holder for Adult and Elderly Services, Councillor Mrs V.J. Leighton, responded as follows:

“The figures have been calculated by the officers. Extra care housing is short in this part of Surrey. This is the first one. It is noted that extra care housing has to have a core number of units to work and a day centre element under Government guidelines. The A2 project has plans for another facility which will have a day centre. Residents are overjoyed at the size and amenity of the apartments afforded in this development.”